Blog · Review
AppCleaner review: measured on seven real apps
AppCleaner is a good free uninstaller, and it leaves shared containers, where chat history lives, unticked. The catches are that it ignores apps that are running without saying why, and its sizes count cloned files in full. RefreshYourMac tells you when an app is running and when you last opened it, so you know whether it is still in use before you remove it.
AppCleaner, from FreeMacSoft, is the uninstaller most people are pointed to when they ask how to remove a Mac app properly. It is free, it is small, and it has been around for years. We make a Mac cleaner with an uninstaller of its own, so rather than repeat what AppCleaner’s page says, we ran both on the same apps on the same Mac and wrote down what each found.
How we tested
- AppCleaner 3.7, downloaded from freemacsoft.net on 3 November 2026. It is signed by its developer and notarised by Apple, and it is 7.5 MB.
- RefreshYourMac’s uninstaller, as it ships in version 1.3.6. Its search code has not changed since 25 September.
- One Mac, running macOS 26.5.2, with seven ordinary third-party apps: Figma, WhatsApp, Capture One, uTorrent Neo, Memory Diag, Google Chrome and DisplayLink Manager.
Each app was opened in both tools and the list of related files written down. Nothing was removed: every list was read and cancelled.
What each one found
| App | AppCleaner | RefreshYourMac | Found by only one |
|---|---|---|---|
| Figma | 7 | 5 | AppCleaner: a 4 KB figma-desktop folder and a 37 KB web storage file |
| 20 | 12 | AppCleaner: two preference files named after the app, two crash reporter files, and three shared containers used by Meta’s apps, with their scripts folders. RefreshYourMac: one helper’s container and its scripts folder | |
| Capture One | 10 | 4 | AppCleaner: three plug-in and culling preference files, and three empty log files |
| Memory Diag | 10 | 8 | AppCleaner: a shared container and scripts folder for the developer’s framework, named with their team ID |
| uTorrent Neo | 3 | 4 | RefreshYourMac: an empty uTorrent Neo folder |
| Google Chrome | — | 2 | AppCleaner showed nothing while Chrome was open. RefreshYourMac also listed Chrome’s profile folder as kept, because it holds saved passwords |
| DisplayLink Manager | — | 2 | The same: it was running |
Counts are leftovers, not counting the app itself. On the five apps both tools listed, AppCleaner found 50 items and RefreshYourMac 33. AppCleaner looks wider: it matches files named after the app as well as its bundle ID, and it reads crash reporter and log files that RefreshYourMac’s uninstaller does not. Almost everything only AppCleaner found was small, a few kilobytes each, but a thorough uninstall is about not leaving things behind, and on that it did better.
Two things it does carefully
It leaves shared containers unticked. Everything in AppCleaner’s list starts ticked except the Group Containers, which it leaves for you to decide. For WhatsApp that is where the chat history and media live, so removing the app does not take your messages with it unless you tick them. RefreshYourMac ticks every item it finds, shared containers included, and relies on you to untick. AppCleaner’s default is the safer one.
Removing goes to the Trash. Files it removes go to the Trash, and the last removal can be undone from the Edit menu. You may be asked for your password for files outside your own Library.
Two catches
It ignores apps that are running. With Chrome and DisplayLink open, AppCleaner showed its empty “Drop your apps here” window and nothing else. To confirm it, we opened Memory Diag in AppCleaner while it was quit, which listed the app and 10 leftovers, then again while it was running, which listed nothing. There was no message saying why. Quit an app before you drop it in.
Its sizes can be far larger than the space you get back. AppCleaner put WhatsApp’s shared
container at 15.73 GB, and du agrees. But that folder is full of APFS clones: when we looked
inside on 30 October, one chat held 909 copies of the same video, all sharing the same space on
disk. RefreshYourMac counts each clone once and put the same folder at 1.43 GB, which is what
deleting it would actually free. AppCleaner is not wrong by the usual measure, since du and
Finder count every clone in full too, but if you
are removing an app for the space, the big number is not what you will get back.
It also asks for Full Disk Access, and says some files may fail to be removed without it. And its own help text warns that it can occasionally match unrelated files, so read the list before you press Remove.
What RefreshYourMac tells you that AppCleaner does not
AppCleaner answers one question: which files belong to this app. It does not tell you whether you are still using the app. RefreshYourMac does, before anything is removed:
- Whether it is running. Open a running app in its uninstaller and the list still appears, with a banner saying the app is running and a button to quit it, because macOS can put a running app’s files straight back.
- When you last opened it. Every app in its list shows when it was last opened, taken from three sources: macOS’s own usage history, Spotlight, and when the app’s program was last read from disk. It takes the latest, because any one of them can be missing.
- Which apps you have stopped using. Its Unused Applications category lists only apps you have not opened in the last 100 days of using your Mac, a number you can change, so a holiday does not make every app look abandoned.
So the question it answers first is whether an app is safe to remove at all, and only then what removing it takes with it.
The verdict
If all you want is to uninstall apps, AppCleaner is free, careful by default, and on our Mac it found more than our own uninstaller did. Quit the app first, read the list, and leave the shared containers unticked unless you mean to lose what is in them.
RefreshYourMac is a different kind of tool: the uninstaller is one part of a cleaner that measures what is taking the space, rates every category for safety, and counts cloned files once. If you want that, it does the job; if you only want to uninstall, start with AppCleaner. For the manual method, see how to uninstall apps on a Mac completely.
What to do next: see these numbers for your own Mac. Download Atzu Storage free, or get it on the Mac App Store.
What it costs to have an app do this
| Atzu Storage | CleanMyMac | MacKeeper | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pay once | $24.99 | €119.95 on MacPaw’s store; $89.99 for CleanMyMac X on the Mac App Store | subscription only |
| Yearly | $14.99 a year, first 7 days free | $39.99/yr on the Mac App Store; €39.95/yr on MacPaw’s store | €71.40 for the first year, 1 Mac. Their page shows it against a €119.40 list price |
| Monthly | $1.99 a month | $9.99/mo | €10.95/mo |
| Account needed | No | Yes | Yes |
Both versions' yearly plans start with 7 days free. CleanMyMac and MacKeeper prices read from their own pages and the Mac App Store on 27 October 2026; the full comparison is at Atzu Storage vs CleanMyMac and MacKeeper.